When you’ve been injured in an accident, choosing the right legal representation can be the difference between receiving fair compensation and settling for much less than you deserve. This critical decision shouldn’t be made lightly, especially when your physical recovery, financial stability, and future well-being are at stake. One of the most valuable tools at your disposal when selecting an accident attorney in New York is the wealth of client reviews available from previous cases.
The Value of Client Testimonials in Legal Representation
Client reviews provide authentic insights into what working with a particular attorney is actually like—beyond the promises made on websites or in advertisements. These firsthand accounts reveal crucial information about an attorney’s communication style, responsiveness, legal strategy, and most importantly, their ability to deliver results.
For accident victims in New York, where the legal landscape is particularly complex and competitive, reviews serve as a critical filtering mechanism to identify attorneys who truly excel at personal injury law. They highlight important qualities that may not be apparent from credentials alone, such as empathy, accessibility, and commitment to client satisfaction.
What Reviews Reveal About Your Potential Attorney
1. Track Record of Success
Perhaps the most important information you’ll glean from client reviews is an attorney’s history of successful outcomes. While every case is different, patterns of positive results indicate an accident attorney in New York who knows how to navigate the legal system effectively.
Mitchell Proner of Proner & Proner, with over 60 years of combined firm experience, has consistently demonstrated exceptional results, as evidenced by numerous client testimonials highlighting substantial settlements and verdicts. One former client notes, “Mitchell Proner is an amazing and very experienced trial lawyer who takes care of his clients… he got me the settlement that I expected.”
2. Genuine Client Relationships
Reviews often reveal how attorneys treat their clients throughout what can be a lengthy and sometimes stressful process. Do they make themselves available for questions? Do they explain complex legal concepts clearly? Do they genuinely care about their clients’ well-being?
Many clients of Proner & Proner specifically mention Mitchell Proner’s personal approach to representation. As one client shared, “Mitchell Proner gives his personal cell phone number to every client,” demonstrating his commitment to accessibility and personal service. Another remarked, “The concern I received was a comfort. The firm’s contact with me while working on my behalf was reassuring.”
3. Expertise in Specific Types of Cases
Not all personal injury attorneys have the same specialties. Reviews can help you identify an accident attorney in New York with specific expertise relevant to your situation, whether it’s a motorcycle accident, construction injury, or slip and fall case.
Mitchell Proner is particularly renowned for his expertise in motorcycle accident cases, not only as an attorney but as someone who understands these cases from personal experience. Having survived a serious motorcycle accident himself in 1990, he brings unique insight to these cases that many reviewers highlight as invaluable.
The amount of time you’re getting treatment, the quality and quantity of visits to doctors, the type of treatment that you get, whether it’s injections, whether you need a surgery, whether you, in fact, have that surgery, diagnostic testing, X-ray, MRIs that come back positive, all these factors will increase the value of your claim.
Red Flags to Watch For in Reviews
While positive reviews can guide you toward excellent representation, negative reviews can be equally informative by alerting you to potential problems:
- Patterns of poor communication or unresponsiveness
- Complaints about unexpected fees or costs
- Mentions of cases being passed off to junior associates
- Indications that the attorney overpromised and underdelivered
- Comments about feeling pressured to accept inadequate settlements
Where to Find Reliable Reviews
The most valuable reviews come from multiple sources, as this provides a more complete picture of an attorney’s reputation:
Google Business and other third-party platforms: These reviews tend to be more objective than those curated on an attorney’s website.
Legal directories: Sites like FindLaw and Super Lawyers include peer reviews and client feedback.
Bar association resources: Many local bar associations provide resources for finding and evaluating attorneys.
Social media: Platforms like Facebook often contain candid client experiences.
Get Advice From An Experienced Personal Injury Lawyer
All You Have To Do Is Call 212-986-3030 To Receive Your Free Case Evaluation.
Mitchell Proner: Your Best Option
While client reviews provide crucial perspectives, professional recognition can further validate an attorney’s capabilities. Mitchell Proner’s extensive professional achievements complement his great client reviews:
Elected President of the New York State Academy of Trial Lawyers
Lifetime member of the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum
Named one of the “Top 100 Trial Lawyers” by the American Trial Lawyers Association
Rated “AV” by Martindale-Hubbell, the highest peer review rating for ethics and skill
These distinctions, combined with positive client experiences, paint a comprehensive picture of an accident attorney in New York who delivers exceptional representation.
The Proner & Proner Difference: What Reviews Consistently Show
Reviews for Mitchell Proner and his team consistently highlight several distinctive qualities that set the firm apart:
Personal attention: Clients repeatedly mention feeling like their case mattered and that they weren’t just another file.
Transparent communication: The firm’s commitment to keeping clients informed throughout the legal process appears in countless testimonials.
Expertise across accident types: Whether handling car accidents, motorcycle crashes, construction incidents, or slip and falls, reviews demonstrate the firm’s versatility and depth of knowledge.
Negotiation skill: Many clients specifically mention the firm’s ability to secure significantly higher settlements than initially offered by insurance companies.
Making Your Decision: Using Reviews Effectively
When using reviews to select an accident attorney in New York, consider the following approach:
Look for specific details rather than vague praise.
Seek out reviews from cases similar to yours.
Pay attention to how recently reviews were posted.
Consider the overall pattern rather than focusing on a single outlier review.
Use reviews as one factor in your decision, alongside credentials, experience, and your personal comfort level during consultation.
Our Advice
The process of selecting an accident attorney in New York should never be rushed or taken lightly. Client reviews provide invaluable insights that can help you identify attorneys who don’t just talk about client service but consistently deliver it.
Mitchell Proner’s remarkable record of positive client experiences, combined with his extensive professional recognition, exemplifies the qualities accident victims should seek in legal representation. As one satisfied client stated, “If you’ve been in an accident, Mitchell Proner is absolutely fantastic!”
When your health, financial security, and future are at stake following an accident, taking the time to research reviews could be the most important step in your journey toward fair compensation and recovery.
We return our clients’ phone calls. We are available 24/7, 365 days a year. I give out my personal cell phone number to all my clients, and I tell them they can feel free to contact me at any time. That’s what makes us different.
