After an accident, finding the right legal representation can make all the difference in the outcome of your case. Unfortunately, not all attorneys have your best interests at heart. At Proner & Proner, with over 60 years of experience handling car, motorcycle, truck, construction, and all types of accidents in New York, we believe in transparency and honest communication with our clients.
Let’s examine some misleading statements that accident attorneys might tell you, why these claims are false, and what the reality is for accident victims seeking justice.
Table of Contents
"You Can Expect a Million-Dollar Settlement"
The Falsehood
The Reality
Reputable accident attorneys know that every case is unique, and outcomes depend on numerous factors including:
- The severity and permanence of your injuries
- Available insurance coverage limits
- Liability factors and comparative negligence
- Documentation of economic and non-economic damages
- Jurisdiction and venue considerations
A trustworthy attorney will conduct a thorough evaluation before discussing potential settlement ranges and will never guarantee specific amounts. They’ll explain the factors that strengthen or potentially limit your claim, setting realistic expectations while still fighting to maximize your recovery.
Visit our spanish website
"We Can Settle Your Case in Just a Few Weeks"
The Falsehood
Unscrupulous lawyers often promise extremely quick resolutions to attract clients who need money immediately. They may claim special relationships with insurance companies or “expedited processes” that can wrap up complex cases in record time.
The Reality
Properly handling an accident case requires time:
- Medical treatment must progress to understand the full extent of injuries
- Maximum medical improvement (MMI) should be reached when possible
- All relevant evidence must be collected and preserved
- Expert witnesses may need to be consulted
- Thorough demand packages must be prepared
While some straightforward cases can resolve relatively quickly, rushing a settlement often means accepting far less compensation than deserved. A good attorney balances efficiency with thoroughness, ensuring you don’t settle before understanding the full extent of your damages.
"Don't Worry About Going to Your Doctor's Appointments"
The Falsehood
Poor legal representatives might downplay the importance of consistent medical care, suggesting that simply filing a claim is sufficient to prove injuries.
The Reality
Medical documentation is the backbone of any injury claim. Missing appointments or having gaps in treatment can severely damage your case by:
- Giving insurance companies reason to argue your injuries aren’t serious
- Creating questions about whether your current symptoms are related to the accident
- Reducing the documented impact of the accident on your daily life
- Limiting the medical evidence that supports your claim
Dedicated accident attorneys emphasize the dual importance of following through with treatment – both for your physical recovery and for establishing a strong legal claim.
"We Handle Everything – You Don't Need to Be Involved"
The Falsehood
Some attorneys promise a completely hands-off experience, telling clients they won’t need to participate in the process at all. While this might sound appealing, it’s a red flag.
The Reality
While good representation should handle the legal complexities, your involvement remains essential:
- Your unique experience and perspective cannot be substituted
- Details about how injuries affect your daily life come directly from you
- Your input on settlement decisions is not just important—it’s your legal right
- Preparing for depositions or testimony requires your active participation
The strongest attorney-client relationships involve collaboration, with the attorney handling legal complexities while keeping you informed and involved in critical decisions about your case.
Watch all our videos here
"Just Sign Here – Don't Worry About the Details"
The Falsehood
Questionable lawyers may rush you through signing agreements, fee structures, or settlement documents without proper explanation, using phrases like “it’s all standard” or “everyone signs these.”
The Reality
Every document you sign has potential consequences:
- Fee agreements establish what percentage of your recovery goes to legal fees
- Medical authorizations determine who can access your health information
- Settlement releases typically eliminate any future right to compensation
- Litigation documents can contain admissions or statements that affect your case
Ethical attorneys take time to explain all documents, encourage questions, and ensure you understand what you’re signing. They recognize that informed clients make better decisions and are more satisfied with the legal process.
Over the past 30 years, I've helped thousands of people just like you get back on their feet and receive the money they truly deserve. My clients have recovered over $500 million in total. Just last month, I won 5 multi-million dollar cases —and many other cases with less severe injuries, because to me, every client is important.
Why Quality Legal Representation Matters
The difference between mediocre and excellent legal representation often determines whether accident victims receive fair compensation. Quality attorneys like Mitchell Proner and his team bring:
- Deep legal knowledge: Understanding the nuances of New York accident law, insurance regulations, and precedent cases
- Investigative resources: Access to accident reconstructionists, medical experts, and other specialists
- Negotiation skill: Experience in countering insurance company tactics designed to minimize payouts
- Trial readiness: The ability and willingness to take cases to court when fair settlements aren’t offered
- Client advocacy: Genuine commitment to your wellbeing and recovery
Why Mitchell Proner and Proner & Proner Stands Apart
With over six decades of experience serving accident victims throughout New York, Proner & Proner has built a reputation based on integrity, results, and client service. Our approach differs from less reputable firms in several key ways:
Honest Case Evaluation
We provide straightforward assessments of your case’s strengths and challenges, establishing realistic expectations while still fighting aggressively for maximum compensation.
Comprehensive Case Preparation
Our thorough preparation includes detailed evidence gathering, expert consultation, and meticulous documentation that positions your case for optimal outcomes.
Direct Attorney Access
Unlike firms where clients rarely speak with their actual attorney, our lawyers maintain direct communication with clients throughout the case process.
Trial-Tested Experience
While many firms settle all cases to avoid courtroom work, our attorneys have extensive trial experience and are prepared to advocate before judges and juries when necessary.
Client-Centered Approach
We recognize that behind every case is a person whose life has been disrupted. Our approach balances legal excellence with compassion and understanding of the human impact of accidents.
Get Advice From An Experienced Personal Injury Lawyer
All You Have To Do Is Call 1-800-321-1234 To Receive Your Free Case Evaluation.
Let’s take the next step
If you’ve been injured in an accident in New York, choosing the right legal representation is one of the most important decisions you’ll make. At Proner & Proner, we believe in setting honest expectations, providing expert guidance, and fighting tirelessly for the compensation our clients deserve.
Don’t let misleading promises from inadequate representation compromise your case. Contact Proner & Proner today for a free consultation with attorneys who will tell you the truth about your accident claim and provide the quality representation needed to pursue justice:
We return our clients’ phone calls. We are available 24/7, 365 days a year. I give out my personal cell phone number to all my clients, and I tell them they can feel free to contact me at any time. That’s what makes us different.
