Is It Worth Hiring a Lawyer If the Insurance Company Already Offered Me Money After My Motorcycle Accident in New York?

Injured motorcyclist in New York talking to a lawyer about an insurance settlement offer.

Motorcycle accidents in New York can change your life instantly. Between medical bills, lost wages, and emotional stress, the last thing you want is a battle with the insurance company. When an insurer quickly offers you money after your crash, you may wonder: “Should I just take it and move on, or do I need a lawyer?”

The truth is that accepting an insurance company’s first offer without speaking to a motorcycle accident lawyer in New York can leave you with far less than you deserve. Understanding how insurers operate—and how a lawyer can protect you—could make the difference between financial hardship and real recovery.

Table of Contents

We return our clients’ phone calls. We are available 24/7, 365 days a year. I give out my personal cell phone number to all my clients, and I tell them they can feel free to contact me at any time. That’s what makes us different.

Why Insurance Companies Make Quick Settlement Offers

Insurance companies are businesses. Their priority is to protect profits, not to look out for injured riders. Here’s why their first offer is rarely enough:

  • Speed over fairness: They hope you accept before realizing the long-term costs of your accident.
  • Incomplete coverage: Their offers often ignore ongoing medical treatment, physical therapy, and future lost income.
  • Pressure tactics: They may imply that this is the best you’ll get or that waiting will delay your compensation.

For many motorcyclists, the initial check might look tempting—but it almost never reflects the true value of your claim.

What a Motorcycle Accident Lawyer in New York Brings to the Table

Hiring a personal injury lawyer shifts the balance of power. Insurance adjusters know attorneys won’t settle for less. A skilled motorcycle accident attorney NYC can:

  • Assess full damages including medical bills, rehabilitation, lost wages, and pain and suffering.
  • Investigate liability to make sure the insurance company doesn’t unfairly blame you for the crash.
  • Negotiate strategically using evidence, expert opinions, and legal leverage.
  • Litigate if necessary—insurance companies often raise their offers once they see you’re willing to go to court.

At ProLaw, our attorneys have handled countless cases where insurers tried to push lowball offers. In nearly every case, our clients recovered far more with legal representation than they would have on their own.

With 30 years of experience winning top settlements, we know how to deal with insurance companies and the legal system. You’re in the best hands with us.

Common Questions Riders Ask

“If I take the insurance company’s money, can I sue later?”

Usually, no. Once you accept a settlement and sign a release, your case is closed. That’s why consulting with a lawyer first is essential.

“What if the offer seems fair?”

It might look reasonable, but without expert review, you won’t know if it covers hidden costs like surgeries, therapy, or long-term income loss.

“How much more can a lawyer really get me?”

While every case is unique, national data shows that represented accident victims often receive several times more than those who accept early offers.

Why Motorcycle Accidents Require Special Attention

Motorcycle crashes tend to cause more severe injuries than typical car accidents. Riders face broken bones, spinal injuries, and head trauma—often requiring months or years of recovery. These cases also involve unique liability issues, such as road hazards, driver negligence, or defective bike parts.

Because the stakes are higher, hiring the best motorcycle accident lawyer in New York is not just a smart move—it may be the only way to secure enough compensation to truly rebuild your life.

Don’t Let the Insurance Company Decide Your Future

The insurance company’s first offer is designed to save them money, not to secure your future. If you sign too quickly, you may find yourself paying out of pocket for medical expenses or struggling financially while you recover.

With a lawyer by your side, you have someone fighting exclusively for your interests—someone who knows how to challenge insurers and win maximum compensation.

When you’re injured in a motorcycle accident in New York, you only get one chance to settle your case the right way. Accepting the insurance company’s initial offer may feel convenient, but it almost always means leaving money on the table.

Instead, consult with a motorcycle accident lawyer New York before making any decisions. At ProLaw, we offer free consultations and only get paid if you win. That means there’s no risk—only the possibility of recovering what you truly deserve.

Yes, You Can Sue

Don’t gamble with your future. If the insurance company has offered you money after a motorcycle accident, contact Proner & Proner at 1-800-321-1234. Let our experienced attorneys review your case and fight for the full compensation you’re entitled to.

FAQ

Yes, although it may affect the compensation amount. Speak with a lawyer to evaluate your specific case.

New York follows a “comparative negligence” rule, meaning you can still receive compensation even if you were partly responsible.

In New York, you generally have up to 3 years to file a personal injury claim. The sooner you act, the better your chances of success.

Were you injured in a motorcycle accident caused by poor road conditions?

Don’t wait. Consult an attorney today and protect your rights.

Recent Entries

Injured motorcyclist without helmet in New York being assisted by a police officer after an accident
Motorcycle Accident

Can I Sue If I Had a Motorcycle Accident Without a Helmet in New York?

A motorcycle accident can be devastating. In a busy city like New York, where the streets are full of cars, trucks, and pedestrians, motorcyclists face ...
Read More
Motorcyclist arguing with police officer after accident in New York
Motorcycle Accident

What to Do If the Police Didn’t File a Report After Your Motorcycle Accident in New York

Motorcycle accidents are stressful enough, but what happens if the police don’t file an official report? In New York, a police accident report can play ...
Read More
ealistic depiction of a motorcycle accident in New York City where a motorcyclist, visibly injured, speaks with another person while a damaged car and motorcycle remain in the background. Perfect for illustrating comparative negligence cases.
Uncategorized

What Happens If the Motorcyclist Was Partially at Fault in a New York Accident?

Motorcycle accidents in New York can be complex, especially when the motorcyclist is found to share some of the blame. In these cases, the state’s ...
Read More
Motociclista herido en el pavimento tras chocar con un camión comercial rojo en una calle de Nueva York, con moto dañada y transeúntes observando.
Motorcycle Accident

Accidents Involving Motorcycles and Commercial Vehicles in New York: Who Can You Sue?

Motorcycle accidents are already dangerous, but when they involve large commercial vehicles—such as trucks, delivery vans, or buses—the consequences can be catastrophic. If you’ve been ...
Read More
Motorcyclist collides with open car door in New York City traffic, representing a dooring accident case.
Uncategorized

Who Is Responsible if a Driver Opens Their Car Door and Hits a Motorcyclist in New York City?

Motorcycle accidents in New York City happen for many reasons, but one of the most overlooked is the dooring incident — when a driver or ...
Read More
Damaged black motorcycle in a New York accident with visible black box as evidence
Motorcycle Accident

How a Black Box on Your Motorcycle Can Help You Win Your Case – Motorcycle Accident Lawyer in New York

Motorcycle accidents are often chaotic, fast, and hard to reconstruct. If you’ve been in an accident in New York and were injured, proving what really ...
Read More

Let Proner & Proner In New York City Help You

If you have been in an accident, or need a lawyer to help a loved one, please contact us by filling out our website form, or call us directly at the number listed above.

Our firm will use its 50 years of experience to answer all the questions you may have at no cost to you. Please contact us when you’re ready. We are here to help you.