When Robert Keller suffered a serious construction accident in 2016, he had no idea that his path to justice would take seven years. But with Mitchell Proner by his side, Keller eventually secured a multimillion-dollar settlement that changed his life.
“Mitchell is a razor sharp litigator,” says Keller, reflecting on his long legal journey. “The experts Mitchell puts on your behalf are better than anybody else that any defense attorney can put out.” Keller’s enthusiasm for Proner’s legal skills doesn’t stop there. He adds, “Mitchell is absolutely fantastic!”
But what exactly makes Mitchell Proner stand out as one of New York’s premier personal injury attorneys? His 30+ years of experience has established him as a formidable force in the courtroom. Here are five reasons why Mitchell Proner has earned his reputation as a “razor sharp litigator” and why accident victims across New York turn to him in their time of need.
1. A Personal Understanding of Accident Trauma
What truly sets Mitchell Proner apart from other personal injury attorneys is that he’s been exactly where many of his clients have been. In 1990, Mitchell was riding his 1988 Harley-Davidson Sportster when a taxi ran a red light and struck him. The accident left him with a broken wrist, ankle, and multiple fractures in his back, requiring several operations and lengthy hospital stays.
This firsthand experience gives Mitchell a unique perspective that few attorneys possess. He doesn’t just intellectually understand his clients’ pain and suffering—he’s lived it. This personal connection allows him to fight with unmatched passion and authenticity for his clients, particularly in motorcycle accident cases where riders often face unfair bias.
2. A Record of Multimillion-Dollar Victories
Mitchell Proner hasn’t just won cases—he’s consistently secured life-changing settlements for his clients. With over $500 million in recovered compensation, Proner has established himself as an attorney who gets results. Since 1994, he has obtained multimillion-dollar verdicts and settlements every single year, demonstrating remarkable consistency in achieving substantial victories for his clients.
Construction accident cases like Robert Keller’s are particularly complex, often involving multiple liable parties and intricate workers’ compensation issues. Mitchell Proner navigates these complexities with strategic precision, identifying all potential avenues for compensation and fighting relentlessly until justice is served.
3. Unmatched Trial Expertise Across Jurisdictions
Few attorneys can match Mitchell Proner’s extensive trial experience. He has successfully represented clients in over 30 jurisdictions across five continents, making him truly a global advocate for the injured. This international experience has honed his adaptive litigation skills and exposed him to a wide variety of legal strategies.
His expertise is so respected that he regularly lectures to Bar Associations and attorney groups throughout the United States, Canada, and Europe on how to represent accident victims effectively. When other attorneys want to learn how to litigate personal injury cases successfully, they turn to Mitchell Proner.
4. Recognition from the Legal Community
The legal community has consistently recognized Mitchell Proner’s exceptional abilities. His awards and accomplishments include:
- President of the New York State Academy of Trial Lawyers
- Lifetime member of the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum
- Named one of the “Top 100 Trial Lawyers” by the American Trial Lawyers Association for over a decade
- Selected as a “Super Lawyer” for 15 consecutive years
- Rated “AV” by Martindale-Hubbell, the highest possible peer review rating for ethics and advocacy skills
- Director Emeritus (lifetime member) of the New York State Trial Lawyers Association
These prestigious honors reflect the respect Proner has earned from judges, fellow attorneys, and the legal community at large. When insurance companies see Mitchell Proner’s name on a case, they know they’re facing a formidable opponent with an established track record of success.
5. Unparalleled Client Commitment
Perhaps most importantly, Mitchell Proner demonstrates an extraordinary level of commitment to his clients. While many attorneys remain distant and difficult to reach, Mitchell gives every client his personal cell phone number. He makes himself directly available, typically responding to calls within 24 hours.
This accessibility reflects Proner’s philosophy that successful representation requires a genuine personal connection. He doesn’t just see cases—he sees people who are suffering and need a powerful advocate in their corner. As Robert Keller experienced during his seven-year legal battle, Mitchell Proner stays committed for the long haul, no matter how complex or challenging the case may become.
The experts Mitchell puts on your behalf are better than anybody else that any defense attorney can put out
When Experience Matters Most
For accident victims facing life-altering injuries, the choice of attorney can make all the difference. Mitchell Proner brings over 60 years of combined firm experience to every case, from construction accidents and vehicle collisions to slip and falls and workplace injuries. His team’s expertise across a wide spectrum of personal injury law ensures that clients receive sophisticated, comprehensive representation.
Robert Keller’s story—seven years of persistent legal action resulting in a multimillion-dollar settlement—exemplifies the Proner & Proner approach. The firm understands that some cases require extraordinary patience and determination. When Mitchell Proner takes on a case, he commits to seeing it through to a successful conclusion, no matter how long it takes.
For New Yorkers facing the aftermath of serious accidents, Mitchell Proner offers more than just legal representation. He offers the security of knowing that one of the nation’s most accomplished personal injury attorneys—a truly “razor sharp litigator”—is fighting relentlessly for their rights and their future.
If you’ve been injured in an accident, don’t settle for less than the best. Contact Proner & Proner today:
Get Advice From An Experienced Personal Injury Lawyer
All You Have To Do Is Call 1-800-321-1234 To Receive Your Free Case Evaluation.
How Proner & Proner Can Help
In 1990, Mitchell Proner experienced several broken bones in his back as a result of a serious motorcycle accident when a taxi ran a red light and collided with him. While he was fortunate enough to recover and return to work, he understands the pain and trauma accident victims experience.
Mitchell Proner’s father, A. Stanley Proner, founded our firm in 1958 with a clients-first philosophy, and Mitchell continues his father’s legacy to this day:
We return our clients’ phone calls. We are available 24/7, 365 days a year. I give out my personal cell phone number to all my clients, and I tell them they can feel free to contact me at any time. That’s what makes us different.
