You were in a motorcycle accident. You’re injured, your bike is destroyed, and you’re still trying to process what happened… when you find out the other driver is lying.
Maybe they claim you caused the accident. Or that you were speeding. They might even say you cut them off or that they had the right of way.
It’s frustrating, unfair, and it could put your case at risk.
But don’t worry: there are ways to defend yourself and prove the truth.
Table of Contents
We return our clients’ phone calls. We are available 24/7, 365 days a year. I give out my personal cell phone number to all my clients, and I tell them they can feel free to contact me at any time. That’s what makes us different.
Why Do Some Drivers Lie After an Accident?
Unfortunately, it’s not uncommon for a driver to lie in order to:
- Avoid a hike in their insurance
- Hide the fact they were distracted or reckless
- Conceal that they don’t have valid insurance
- Manipulate the situation, especially if the other person was on a motorcycle (a common bias)
But just because someone says something doesn’t mean it’s true, or that you can’t prove otherwise.
What If the Driver Changes Their Story?
This happens often. A driver might admit fault at the scene but later tell the police or their insurer something different.
That’s why, from the start, it’s essential to:
- Document everything that happened
- Write down (or record) anything the other driver says
- Get witnesses who saw and heard what happened
They can change their story. You need to have solid evidence
With 30 years of experience winning top settlements, we know how to deal with insurance companies and the legal system. You’re in the best hands with us.
How Can You Prove the Other Driver Is Lying?
A motorcycle accident lawyer can help with several legal strategies:
- Camera footage
Traffic cams, nearby businesses, or dashcams can all provide crucial evidence. - Accident reconstruction
Experts analyze impact points, damage, skid marks, and vehicle positions to determine what really happened. - Eyewitnesses
Neutral witnesses can be key. Their statements can support your version. - Medical records
The type and location of your injuries can help prove how the accident occurred and contradict false claims. - Phone records
If the other driver was using their phone, this distraction can be proven and used to question their credibility.
Who Decides Who's Telling the Truth?
Not the other driver. Not their insurer.
A legal investigation, judge, or jury makes that decision, based on the evidence.
That’s why you need a law firm that knows how to:
- Collect solid evidence right away
- Legally refute lies
- Defend your version of events and protect your rights
What You Should NOT Do If the Other Driver Is Lying
- Don’t confront them directly — it can backfire.
- Don’t talk to their insurance company without legal advice.
- Don’t assume everything will sort itself out. It often doesn’t.
A lie handled poorly can seriously damage your claim.
What You SHOULD Do
- Seek medical attention immediately.
- Call the police and make sure an official report is filed.
- Take photos and videos of the scene, the damage, and your physical condition.
- Write down the time, location, driver and witness details.
Proner & Proner: Motorcycle Defenders in New York
If the other driver is lying about the accident, you need a law firm that knows how to act and how to win, especially in a complex place like New York City.
At Proner & Proner:
- We’ve defended motorcyclists in cases where no one believed them.
- We know how to take on aggressive insurance companies and dishonest drivers.
- We protect your truth, your reputation, and your compensation.
We handle cases in NYC, Queens, Brooklyn, the Bronx, and the metro area.
Call 1-800-321-1234 or fill out our online form.
Your story deserves to be heard. We’ll make sure it’s also believed.
